Elm Street Historic District, White Plains, VA

Elm Street Historic District Neighborhood Overview

Overview

The Elm Street Historic District is a picturesque and architecturally significant neighborhood located just north of downtown White Plains. Established as the city's first historic district in 1979, it encompasses roughly 40 properties along Elm Street, Brookfield Street, and part of North Broadway. This area was developed primarily between 1890 and 1930 as a prestigious residential enclave for White Plains' prosperous merchants, professionals, and civic leaders, offering a suburban feel within walking distance of the city center.

The district's character is defined by its remarkable collection of late-Victorian, Colonial Revival, Tudor Revival, and Craftsman-style homes. Mature trees line the quiet, gently curving streets, creating a serene atmosphere that feels removed from the adjacent urban bustle. Its location provides the best of both worlds: a peaceful, historic residential setting just minutes from the Metro-North train station, the Westchester County Center, and the shops and offices of downtown White Plains.

Housing & Real Estate

The housing stock is exclusively comprised of single-family homes, ranging from grand, stately mansions to more modest but equally charming bungalows and revival-style houses. Architectural integrity is paramount, with homeowners subject to design review by the city's Historic Preservation Commission for exterior alterations, ensuring the district's cohesive historic character is maintained. Properties often sit on generous, landscaped lots, a rarity so close to the city core.

Real estate in the Elm Street Historic District is among the most coveted and expensive in White Plains. Prices typically range from the high $1 millions to well over $3 million for the most significant estates. The market is almost entirely owner-occupied, with rental properties being exceptionally rare. Recent trends show strong, steady demand for these historic homes, driven by buyers seeking architectural character, a prime location, and a sound long-term investment in a protected neighborhood.

Schools & Education

Families in the Elm Street Historic District are served by the White Plains City School District. The neighborhood is zoned for the highly regarded Mamaroneck Avenue School (MAS) for elementary education (K-5), known for its diverse student body and strong academic programs. Students then progress to White Plains Middle School and White Plains High School, the latter offering a comprehensive curriculum, extensive Advanced Placement courses, and renowned arts and athletics programs.

In addition to the public system, the neighborhood's central location provides easy access to several prestigious private and parochial schools in the greater White Plains area. These include The School of the Holy Child, Rye Country Day School, and various academies in nearby communities. The proximity to downtown also means the White Plains Public Library, with its extensive resources and programming, is just a short walk or drive away.

Parks & Recreation

While the district itself is primarily residential, it is flanked by significant green spaces. Just to the west lies the expansive Saxon Woods Park, a 700-acre county park featuring a public golf course, swimming pool, playgrounds, picnic areas, and miles of walking trails. To the east, residents can easily access the White Plains Rural Cemetery, which, with its park-like setting and historic monuments, functions as a de facto arboretum and quiet walking path.

Recreational facilities are abundant nearby. The Westchester County Center, adjacent to the district, hosts concerts, sports events, and trade shows. The city's recreation department offers numerous programs, and the downtown area features modern fitness centers and studios. For outdoor enthusiasts, the Bronx River Pathway and the extensive trail system of the Westchester County parks are a short drive away.

Local Dining & Shopping

The neighborhood's greatest commercial asset is its walkability to the vibrant downtown White Plains dining and retail scene. Just a few blocks south, residents find a diverse array of restaurants, from upscale steakhouses like Ruth's Chris and Morton's to casual eateries, ethnic cuisines, and popular cafes. The nearby Mamaroneck Avenue "Restaurant Row" and the revitalized Bank Street area offer endless options for a night out or a quick bite.

For shopping, the Westchester Mall, with its high-end department stores and boutiques, is less than a mile away. Downtown also provides everyday conveniences, including a Whole Foods Market, specialty food shops, and a variety of service-oriented local businesses. While Elm Street itself is purely residential, this immediate access to comprehensive urban amenities is a key part of the district's appeal.

Who Lives Here

The Elm Street Historic District attracts a discerning population that values history, architecture, and a tranquil living environment without sacrificing urban convenience. Residents often include professionals commuting to New York City, established families invested in the community and school system, and empty-nesters who appreciate the walkability and cultural offerings. There is a strong sense of stewardship among homeowners, who are typically committed to preserving their properties' historic integrity.

The community vibe is one of quiet pride and neighborliness, with an engaged population that often participates in local preservation and civic affairs. The district draws those seeking a unique, character-rich home rather than a modern development—people who appreciate original woodwork, varied architectural styles, and the narrative of a home with a past. It is a tight-knit, yet not insular, neighborhood that forms a cherished historic core within the ever-modernizing city of White Plains.

Elm Street Historic District Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in Elm Street Historic District, White Plains

Nearby Neighborhoods in White Plains, VA

← Back to all White Plains, VA real estate agents

← Back to all Virginia real estate agents