Lake Telemark, Staten Island, NY

Lake Telemark Neighborhood Overview

Lake Telemark is a unique and secluded residential enclave nestled within the larger neighborhood of Travis, on Staten Island's West Shore. Its defining feature is the private, spring-fed 13-acre lake of the same name, around which the community was developed in the mid-20th century. Originally conceived as a summer bungalow colony, it has transformed into a year-round neighborhood with a distinct, quiet character that feels more like a upstate lake community than a part of New York City.

The neighborhood is geographically defined by Victory Boulevard to the north, the William T. Davis Wildlife Refuge to the south, and the bustling Travis Avenue to the east. This positioning creates a sense of remove and tranquility, yet it remains within a reasonable commute to Manhattan via the Staten Island Expressway. The history and layout of Lake Telemark foster a tight-knit atmosphere where residents share a direct connection to the natural waterfront, a rarity in the urban landscape.

Housing & Real Estate

The housing stock in Lake Telemark is predominantly composed of single-family homes, ranging from the original mid-century ranches and Cape Cods to larger, modernized colonials and split-levels built on generous lots. Many properties boast direct lake frontage or are situated on quiet, winding streets just steps from the water. The architectural style is generally suburban, with an emphasis on privacy and outdoor living space, including decks, patios, and mature landscaping.

Home prices in Lake Telemark are typically above the Staten Island median, reflecting the desirability of the private lake access and the secluded environment. The market is almost exclusively owner-occupied, with very few rental or multi-family units. Recent trends have seen significant renovations and teardowns of older homes, replaced with larger, contemporary residences, though the community's architectural review board works to maintain a cohesive aesthetic and prevent overdevelopment.

Schools & Education

Lake Telemark is zoned within New York City's District 31. Students typically attend Public School 26 in nearby Travis for elementary grades, which has a community-oriented reputation. For middle school, students often feed into I.S. 72 or I.S. 7. High school options include the nearby Port Richmond High School or various specialized public high schools across the borough, accessible through the city's competitive application process.

Given the family-oriented nature of the neighborhood, many residents also explore Staten Island's range of private and parochial school options. These include St. Joseph-St. Thomas School in nearby Pleasant Plains, Staten Island Academy, and Moore Catholic High School. The neighborhood's proximity to the College of Staten Island in Willowbrook also provides local access to higher education and continuing adult education programs.

Parks & Recreation

The centerpiece of recreation is, unequivocally, Lake Telemark itself. The private lake is managed by the Lake Telemark Property Owners Association, which maintains it for swimming, fishing (stocked with bass and catfish), and non-motorized boating like kayaking and canoeing. The association also oversees a beach area and hosts community events, making the lake the social and recreational heart of the neighborhood.

Beyond the lake, residents have access to significant public green spaces. The William T. Davis Wildlife Refuge, a 260-acre preserve of freshwater wetlands and meadows, borders the community to the south, offering extensive trails for birdwatching, hiking, and nature study. The nearby Latourette Park and Golf Course provides a public 18-hole golf course, scenic parkland, and historic buildings, adding to the area's abundant outdoor amenities.

Local Dining & Shopping

Daily conveniences and dining in Lake Telemark are primarily found along the Travis Avenue commercial corridor and in the adjacent Charleston shopping plaza. This area features essential services like a Stop & Shop supermarket, pharmacy chains, hardware stores, and a mix of casual dining establishments including pizzerias, diners, and Chinese takeout. The famous "Killmeyer's Old Bavaria Inn" on Arthur Kill Road provides a landmark destination for German cuisine and beer in a historic setting.

For more extensive shopping and diverse restaurant options, residents typically drive to the Staten Island Mall area in New Springville or the revitalized Historic Richmond Town. The neighborhood's secluded character means it is not a destination for boutique shopping or nightlife, which aligns with residents' preference for a quiet, residential setting. Most consider the trade-off for peace and natural beauty well worth the short drive to larger commercial centers.

Who Lives Here

Lake Telemark attracts residents who prioritize privacy, nature, and a strong sense of community over urban density and walkability. The population is largely composed of established families, professionals, and long-time Staten Islanders who value the unique lakefront lifestyle. It is a neighborhood where neighbors know each other, often through shared activities centered on the lake and community association events.

The demographic tends to be middle to upper-middle class, with many households having deep roots in the area. People are drawn here specifically for the opportunity to have a waterfront home with outdoor recreational opportunities literally in their backyard, all while remaining within the city limits. The vibe is decidedly suburban, quiet, and family-friendly, appealing to those seeking a retreat-like atmosphere without completely leaving the infrastructure of New York City behind.

Lake Telemark Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in Lake Telemark, Staten Island

Nearby Neighborhoods in Staten Island, NY

Explore Top10Lists.us

Verification & Transparency

• Transparency
• Crawl Stats
• Methodology
• Ranking Methodology