Myrtle, Buffalo, WV

Myrtle Neighborhood Overview

Overview

Myrtle, often referred to as the Myrtle Street neighborhood or part of the broader West Side, is a historic and architecturally rich residential area in Buffalo, New York. It is generally bounded by Richmond Avenue to the west, West Ferry Street to the north, and the Scajaquada Expressway to the south, placing it just west of the Elmwood Village and north of the Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus. The neighborhood's core is defined by its namesake, Myrtle Avenue, a picturesque, tree-lined street that serves as its spine.

Developed primarily in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, Myrtle was home to Buffalo's burgeoning professional and merchant class. Its history is etched in its stunning housing stock, featuring an impressive collection of Queen Anne, Colonial Revival, and Arts and Crafts style homes. Today, it retains a quiet, almost village-like atmosphere despite its proximity to bustling commercial districts, offering a serene retreat of historic charm within the city's urban fabric.

Housing & Real Estate

The housing stock in Myrtle is predominantly composed of large, single-family homes, many of which are meticulously maintained historic gems. These include grand Victorians, stately Colonials, and substantial American Foursquares, often featuring intricate woodwork, stained glass, and spacious front porches. The neighborhood also contains some well-kept double homes and a limited number of smaller bungalows and apartment units, particularly on its periphery.

Real estate in Myrtle is highly sought-after, with prices reflecting its historic significance and prime location. Home values are consistently among the highest in the city, often ranging from the mid-$300,000s to well over $700,000 for the most elaborate historic properties. The market is overwhelmingly owner-occupied, contributing to a strong sense of stewardship and community stability. Recent trends show continued demand, with homes selling quickly, often after sensitive renovations that modernize interiors while preserving historic character.

Schools & Education

Myrtle is served by Buffalo Public Schools, with many children attending nearby School 81, the Native American Magnet School, which offers a unique curriculum focused on Native American culture and history. For middle and high school, students typically feed into City Honors School, one of the top-ranked public schools in New York State, though admission is based on a competitive exam.

The neighborhood's proximity to the Elmwood Village also places it near several private and parochial school options, including the Nichols School, Nardin Academy, and Buffalo Seminary. Higher education institutions are easily accessible, with the University at Buffalo's South Campus and Buffalo State University just a short drive or bus ride away, adding a collegiate influence to the area.

Parks & Recreation

Residents enjoy easy access to some of Buffalo's finest green spaces. The neighborhood is just blocks from the renowned Delaware Park, designed by Frederick Law Olmsted. This 350-acre park offers the Rose Garden, the Buffalo Zoo, the Buffalo History Museum, the Albright-Knox Northland, golf, tennis, walking trails around Hoyt Lake, and expansive sports fields.

Closer to home, the smaller Margaret L. Wendt Park, located at the intersection of West Ferry and Normal Avenue, provides a more intimate setting with playground equipment and open green space. The Scajaquada Creek Path, which runs along the neighborhood's southern border, offers a paved trail for walking, running, and biking, connecting to the larger Olmsted parkway system and the Niagara River.

Local Dining & Shopping

While Myrtle itself is primarily residential, its greatest asset is its adjacency to the vibrant commercial corridors of Elmwood Avenue and Hertel Avenue. A short walk east brings residents to the heart of the Elmwood Village, with its dense array of independent boutiques, cafes, restaurants, and specialty shops. Popular spots like Lexington Co-op for groceries, Spot Coffee for a casual meetup, and a wide range of dining from casual to upscale are all within easy reach.

To the north, Hertel Avenue's renaissance offers another world of options, known for its diverse international restaurants, trendy bars, and unique retail. For daily needs, the Tops Friendly Markets on Niagara Street and the Wegmans on Amherst Street are both convenient drives. This proximity allows Myrtle residents to enjoy a quiet home life with the city's best amenities literally just around the corner.

Who Lives Here

Myrtle attracts a mix of professionals, academics, medical professionals from the nearby campus, and long-time Buffalonians who have cherished the neighborhood for generations. The population tends to be well-educated, with a high percentage of homeowners who are deeply invested in the preservation and community spirit of the area. It is a neighborhood of gardeners, porch-sitters, and history enthusiasts.

The community vibe is one of quiet pride and active engagement. Neighbors know one another, and there is a strong commitment to maintaining the area's architectural integrity and lush, tree-canopied streets. People are drawn to Myrtle for its unparalleled historic beauty, its walkability to major city attractions, and its ability to offer a peaceful, family-friendly environment within the dynamic setting of a resurgent Buffalo.

Myrtle Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in Myrtle, Buffalo

Nearby Neighborhoods in Buffalo, WV

← Back to all Buffalo, WV real estate agents

← Back to all West Virginia real estate agents