Martintown, Buffalo, WV

Martintown Neighborhood Overview

Overview

Martintown, located in the heart of Buffalo's East Side, is a historic neighborhood with a rich industrial past and a present defined by community resilience and revitalization. Bounded roughly by Broadway to the north, Fillmore Avenue to the west, and the Buffalo River to the south, its identity is deeply tied to its Polish and German immigrant roots, which shaped its dense streetscape of worker housing and its once-thriving commercial corridors along Broadway and Fillmore.

Today, Martintown is a neighborhood in transition, characterized by a mix of well-preserved historic homes, vacant lots turned into community gardens, and active redevelopment projects. Its location adjacent to the Buffalo River and the burgeoning Larkinville district to the west places it at a strategic crossroads, attracting new investment while maintaining a strong sense of history. The neighborhood's character is one of quiet streets, enduring community institutions, and a palpable sense of potential.

Housing & Real Estate

The housing stock in Martintown is predominantly composed of classic Buffalo worker housing, including compact single-family homes, doubles, and some larger multi-family units, many built in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Architectural styles include simple but sturdy American Foursquares, gable-front homes, and some Victorian-era wood-frame houses. A significant portion of the housing is owner-occupied, often by long-term residents, but there is also a notable stock of rental properties.

Real estate prices in Martintown are among the most affordable in the city, making it a key entry point for first-time homebuyers and investors. Recent trends show a gradual increase in values as spillover interest from Larkinville and targeted city-led revitalization efforts take hold. The neighborhood presents a unique opportunity for those interested in historic preservation and community-building, with many homes requiring renovation, alongside newly constructed infill housing projects aimed at stabilizing blocks.

Schools & Education

Martintown is served by Buffalo Public Schools. The local elementary school is often the well-regarded Dr. Charles R. Drew Science Magnet School, which focuses on science and math, though specific school assignments can vary. High school students may attend nearby McKinley High School or apply to one of the city's magnet or charter school options. The quality of district schools is a point of community focus, with active parent and neighborhood associations advocating for resources.

For private and faith-based education, the historic St. Stanislaus Bishop & Martyr Church complex has long been a cornerstone, though its school has closed. Families in the area often explore a range of educational choices, including other Catholic schools in adjacent neighborhoods and the growing number of charter school options in Buffalo. The neighborhood's proximity to downtown also places it within reach of Erie Community College and SUNY Buffalo State for higher education.

Parks & Recreation

Martintown's primary green space is the expansive and historic Broadway Fillmore Park, a linear park running along Fillmore Avenue. It serves as a community hub for casual recreation, playgrounds, and neighborhood gatherings. The park's design and recent improvements reflect the area's Polish heritage. Additionally, the neighborhood's southern edge is defined by the Buffalo River, offering potential for future greenway and recreational development as part of city-wide riverfront revitalization plans.

Recreational facilities are more community-oriented than large-scale. The neighborhood is home to several active social clubs, including the Polish Cadets and other fraternal organizations that host events and serve as de facto community centers. For more extensive athletic facilities, residents often utilize resources in nearby neighborhoods or the city's larger park system, such as Cazenovia Park to the south, which is a short drive away.

Local Dining & Shopping

Martintown's commercial life is centered on its historic corridors, particularly Broadway and Fillmore Avenue. While these avenues have seen decline, they retain iconic, family-run Polish eateries and bakeries that draw visitors from across the region. Establishments like the legendary Broadway Market, especially bustling during Easter, offer traditional Polish foods, meats, and baked goods, serving as a vital cultural and economic anchor.

Day-to-day shopping includes several neighborhood corner stores and bodegas. For full-service grocery shopping, residents typically travel to nearby Tops Markets on Broadway or other larger retailers in adjacent suburbs. The lack of dense retail is a recognized challenge, but new businesses are slowly emerging, including cafes and small restaurants that cater to both long-time residents and new arrivals drawn by the lower cost of living and proximity to downtown and Larkinville's vibrant scene.

Who Lives Here

Martintown is a neighborhood of deep roots and new beginnings. A core population of long-time, often multi-generational Polish-American and African-American families provides a stable, tight-knit community foundation. These residents are deeply connected to the neighborhood's history, its churches, and its social clubs. There is a strong sense of pride and perseverance among this group, who have maintained their homes and community through decades of urban change.

Increasingly, Martintown is attracting a new wave of residents: young artists, students, and urban pioneers seeking affordable housing within minutes of downtown. These newcomers are drawn by the architectural character, the potential for involvement, and the opportunity to be part of a neighborhood's resurgence. The resulting community vibe is a unique blend of old and new Buffalo—a place where historic traditions meet grassroots revitalization, creating a collaborative and evolving urban village.

Martintown Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in Martintown, Buffalo

Nearby Neighborhoods in Buffalo, WV

← Back to all Buffalo, WV real estate agents

← Back to all West Virginia real estate agents