Colon, Buffalo, WV

Colon Neighborhood Overview

Overview

Colon, officially known as the "Elmwood Village," is a historic and vibrant neighborhood located directly west of downtown Buffalo. Its name derives from its distinctive street layout, where major avenues like Elmwood, Delaware, and Richmond radiate out from the central circle of Colonial Circle like spokes on a wheel, creating a "colon" shape. This area is celebrated as one of Buffalo's most desirable and walkable communities, characterized by its stunning early 20th-century architecture, tree-lined streets, and a palpable sense of community engagement.

The neighborhood's history is deeply tied to Buffalo's Gilded Age prosperity, with many of its grand homes built for the city's industrial elite. Today, it retains an elegant, historic charm while fostering a progressive, energetic atmosphere. Centered along the bustling Elmwood Avenue corridor, Colon serves as a cultural and social hub, seamlessly blending residential comfort with a rich array of local businesses, cafes, and cultural institutions, all within close proximity to Buffalo State College and the renowned Albright-Knox Art Gallery.

Housing & Real Estate

The housing stock in Colon is predominantly composed of beautifully maintained early 20th-century homes, including large American Foursquares, ornate Victorians, stately Tudors, and elegant Colonial Revivals. Many feature intricate woodwork, stained glass, and original hardwood floors. The neighborhood also includes a mix of well-kept duplexes and smaller single-family homes on its side streets, as well as some modern apartment buildings and condominiums closer to the commercial strips.

Real estate in Colon is among the most sought-after and expensive in the Buffalo area, reflecting its prime location and historic character. Prices for single-family homes typically range from the mid-$400,000s well into the millions for the most prestigious properties. The market is primarily owner-occupied, though there is a significant rental market, particularly for apartments and upper/lower units. Recent trends show continued strong demand, with homes often selling quickly above asking price, driven by the neighborhood's enduring appeal and limited inventory.

Schools & Education

Families in Colon are served by the Buffalo Public Schools district, with the highly regarded Elmwood Village Charter School being a popular K-8 option with a lottery-based admission system. The neighborhood is also zoned for City Honors School, one of the top-ranked public high schools in New York State, which draws academically talented students from across the city through a competitive application process.

In addition to these strong public options, the area is surrounded by prestigious private institutions, including the Nichols School and Buffalo Seminary. Higher education is also nearby, with Buffalo State College embedded at the neighborhood's northern edge, contributing to the area's youthful and intellectual energy. This combination of high-performing public and private options makes Colon particularly attractive to families prioritizing education.

Parks & Recreation

Colon is exceptionally well-served by green space, most notably by the 350-acre Delaware Park, designed by Frederick Law Olmsted. The park's northern section, "The Meadow," borders the neighborhood, offering vast lawns, walking and biking paths, sports fields, and the Buffalo Zoo. The neighborhood itself is dotted with smaller, charming parks like Colonial Circle and Days Park, which serve as community gathering spots and playgrounds.

Recreational facilities are abundant, with the Delaware Park Ring Road providing a popular route for runners and cyclists. The nearby Buffalo Golf Club and the Marcy Casino (site of The Terrace restaurant) offer leisure activities. The neighborhood's walkable nature itself is a form of recreation, with residents frequently strolling to shops, festivals, and the weekly Elmwood Village Farmers Market, held year-round at Bidwell Parkway.

Local Dining & Shopping

The Elmwood Avenue strip is the beating heart of local commerce, featuring an eclectic and independent mix of boutiques, gift shops, bookstores, and specialty retailers. From high-end home goods at The Plant Shack to unique clothing at Violet, shopping here emphasizes local ownership. For groceries, residents have the Lexington Cooperative Market, a community-owned natural foods store, and the Dash's Market on Delaware Avenue, alongside several smaller specialty food purveyors.

Dining options are diverse and vibrant, catering to all tastes and occasions. The neighborhood boasts cozy cafes like Spot Coffee, acclaimed restaurants such as The Terrace for fine dining, and beloved casual spots like Cole's for burgers and craft beer. International cuisine, from Thai to Middle Eastern, is well-represented. The social scene is anchored by historic taverns and modern wine bars, ensuring a dynamic atmosphere from morning coffee to late-night drinks.

Who Lives Here

Colon attracts a diverse yet predominantly professional demographic, including young families, academics from nearby colleges, empty-nesters, and established professionals. The population tends to be highly educated, civically engaged, and values-oriented, with a strong emphasis on supporting local businesses and community initiatives. The neighborhood has a progressive, arts-friendly vibe, attracting creatives, architects, and those who appreciate historic preservation.

The community vibe is active, friendly, and neighborly. Residents are often seen walking dogs, chatting on front porches, and participating in neighborhood associations and events like the Elmwood Avenue Festival of the Arts. People are drawn to Colon for its unique combination of urban convenience—walkability to shops and restaurants—and the serene, picturesque feel of its residential streets. It represents a quintessential Buffalo lifestyle that balances historic charm with a contemporary, community-focused energy.

Colon Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in Colon, Buffalo

Nearby Neighborhoods in Buffalo, WV

← Back to all Buffalo, WV real estate agents

← Back to all West Virginia real estate agents