Brentwood Hills, Erie, PA

Brentwood Hills Neighborhood Overview

Brentwood Hills is a well-established, primarily residential neighborhood located in the northwest corner of Erie, Pennsylvania. Situated north of West 38th Street and west of Powell Avenue, it occupies a gently rolling landscape that gives the area its name. The neighborhood is characterized by its quiet, tree-lined streets, mature landscaping, and a strong sense of community, offering a suburban feel while remaining within the city limits and just a short drive from major commercial corridors and Presque Isle State Park.

Developed predominantly in the mid-20th century, Brentwood Hills reflects the post-war boom and the desire for spacious, single-family homes. Its history is one of steady growth and stability, attracting families and professionals seeking a peaceful environment. The neighborhood's location provides excellent accessibility to Interstates 79 and 90, making commutes to downtown Erie, major employers like Erie Insurance and UPMC Hamot, and the Millcreek Township retail hubs both quick and convenient.

Housing & Real Estate

The housing stock in Brentwood Hills consists largely of classic mid-century ranch-style homes, Cape Cods, and split-levels, many featuring generous lot sizes, basements, and attached garages. Architectural styles are consistent, contributing to the area's cohesive and tidy aesthetic. Home values here are considered above the Erie city average, reflecting the neighborhood's desirability, with prices typically ranging from the mid-$200,000s to the low $400,000s, depending on size, condition, and exact location.

Homeownership is the dominant model, with a very high percentage of owner-occupied residences. The rental market is limited, primarily consisting of a few multi-family units on the neighborhood's edges. Recent trends show steady demand, with homes often selling quickly. Residents take pride in property maintenance, and the neighborhood has seen a wave of thoughtful updates and renovations, further solidifying its status as one of Erie's most stable and sought-after residential enclaves.

Schools & Education

Brentwood Hills is served by the Millcreek Township School District, a significant draw for families. While technically within Erie city limits, this unique arrangement places students in the highly-regarded district known for its strong academic performance and extensive resources. Most students attend Asbury Elementary School, which is just minutes away, before progressing to Walnut Creek Middle School and McDowell High School.

In addition to the public school system, several respected private educational options are nearby, including the Mercyhurst Preparatory School and several Catholic elementary schools. The neighborhood's proximity to Penn State Behrend and Mercyhurst University also provides access to continuing education, cultural events, and library resources, adding an intellectual dimension to the community.

Parks & Recreation

Residents of Brentwood Hills enjoy exceptional access to outdoor recreation. The crown jewel is the 8.5-mile multi-purpose Asbury Woods, which borders the neighborhood to the south and west. This extensive nature preserve offers over 200 acres of forests, wetlands, and trails perfect for hiking, birdwatching, cross-country skiing, and environmental education at the Asbury Woods Nature Center.

For more traditional park amenities, nearby Brown's Farm Park and Scott Park offer playgrounds, sports fields, and picnic areas. The neighborhood's greatest recreational asset, however, is its proximity to Presque Isle State Park, a mere 15-minute drive away. The peninsula's beaches, bike trails, marinas, and fishing spots function as a seasonal backyard for Brentwood Hills families seeking sun, sand, and water activities on Lake Erie.

Local Dining & Shopping

While Brentwood Hills itself is strictly residential, its perimeter and immediate surroundings are rich with convenient shopping and dining options. The bustling Peach Street corridor, just to the east, features national retailers, supermarkets like Wegmans and Whole Foods, and big-box stores. The Liberty Plaza and Millcreek Mall areas provide comprehensive retail therapy, from department stores to specialty shops.

For dining, residents have a wide array of choices within a five-minute drive. Options range from casual family restaurants and popular chains along Upper Peach Street to local favorites like The Skunk & Goat Tavern and Pineapple Eddie Southern Bistro. The nearby West 38th Street strip also offers a variety of quick-service eateries, coffee shops, and essential services, making daily errands exceptionally convenient for neighborhood residents.

Who Lives Here

Brentwood Hills attracts a mix of established families, empty-nesters, and professionals who value tranquility, space, and a strong community ethos. The population is largely stable, with many residents living in the neighborhood for decades, which fosters deep neighborly connections and a well-maintained environment. The community vibe is friendly and quiet, with a noticeable pride of ownership evident in the manicured lawns and seasonal decorations.

This neighborhood particularly appeals to those seeking the benefits of Millcreek Township schools while preferring the specific character and slightly more affordable tax structure of an Erie city neighborhood. It draws individuals who appreciate a private, home-centered lifestyle but still want quick access to Erie's employment centers, healthcare facilities, and the unparalleled recreational opportunities provided by Presque Isle and Asbury Woods. The result is a community of engaged, civic-minded residents who have chosen Brentwood Hills as a long-term home.

Brentwood Hills Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in Brentwood Hills, Erie

Nearby Neighborhoods in Erie, PA

Explore Top10Lists.us

Verification & Transparency

• Transparency
• Crawl Stats
• Methodology
• Ranking Methodology