Mountain Lakes, Staten Island, NY

Mountain Lakes Neighborhood Overview

Overview

Mountain Lakes is a serene, residential neighborhood nestled in the heart of Staten Island, New York. It is situated roughly in the center of the borough, bordered by Todt Hill to the east, Bulls Head to the west, and the expansive Greenbelt to the south. The area is characterized by its hilly, wooded terrain and a distinct sense of seclusion, offering a tranquil, suburban lifestyle within the city limits. Its name is derived from the picturesque man-made lakes and rugged landscape originally developed as part of the "Mountain Lakes Park" subdivision in the early 20th century.

The neighborhood's history is deeply tied to the Staten Island Greenbelt, a vast network of protected parkland. Many of its winding roads and custom-built homes were designed to harmonize with the natural topography, preserving mature trees and rock outcroppings. Unlike the grid-like streets found in much of New York City, Mountain Lakes features curvilinear lanes and cul-de-sacs, emphasizing privacy and a connection to nature. This careful planning has resulted in a cohesive community that feels removed from the urban bustle, yet remains conveniently accessible via major arteries like the Staten Island Expressway and Richmond Avenue.

Housing & Real Estate

The housing stock in Mountain Lakes is predominantly composed of single-family homes, with architectural styles ranging from mid-century ranches and split-levels to larger, custom-built Colonials and contemporaries. Many properties are situated on generously sized, wooded lots that provide ample privacy and backyard space. The neighborhood is almost exclusively owner-occupied, with a very low percentage of rental units, reinforcing its stable, family-oriented character.

Real estate prices in Mountain Lakes are consistently among the highest on Staten Island, reflecting the desirable lot sizes, architectural uniqueness, and peaceful setting. Homes typically list from the high $800,000s into the millions, with premium prices commanded for properties with direct lake frontage or exceptional views. The market is competitive, with homes often receiving multiple offers, as buyers are drawn to the area's established charm, low crime rates, and proximity to both nature and conveniences.

Schools & Education

Mountain Lakes is zoned within New York City's Geographic District 31. Families in the neighborhood are primarily served by Public School 26, The Carteret School, which is well-regarded for its strong academic programs. For middle school, students often attend Intermediate School 72, The Rocco Laurie School. The designated high school is Susan E. Wagner High School, a large, academically rigorous school offering a wide array of Advanced Placement courses and extracurricular activities.

In addition to the public options, Staten Island offers several notable private and parochial schools within a reasonable commute. These include Staten Island Academy, a private K-12 school in nearby Todt Hill, and St. Joseph Hill Academy, a Catholic school for young women. The neighborhood's emphasis on family life is reflected in the high priority residents place on education, with many children participating in the various enrichment programs and sports leagues available throughout the borough.

Parks & Recreation

The defining recreational feature of the neighborhood is its namesake, the Mountain Lakes Park section of the Staten Island Greenbelt. This area encompasses three man-made lakes—Upper Lake, Middle Lake, and Lower Lake—surrounded by hiking trails that connect to the broader 2,800-acre Greenbelt network. Residents enjoy direct access to walking, trail running, and birdwatching in a beautifully forested setting right outside their doors, a rarity in New York City.

Beyond the lakes, the wider Greenbelt offers extensive recreational facilities, including the nearby Willowbrook Park, which features a carousel, playgrounds, and sports fields. The Greenbelt Recreation Center, off Brielle Avenue, provides an indoor pool, gymnasium, and fitness classes. For golf enthusiasts, the LaTourette Golf Course is just minutes away. This abundance of green space is central to the neighborhood's identity, promoting an active, outdoor-oriented lifestyle for all ages.

Local Dining & Shopping

Mountain Lakes itself is strictly residential, with no commercial corridors within its core. However, it is conveniently positioned near several major shopping and dining hubs on Staten Island. The bustling Richmond Avenue corridor, a short drive to the west, offers a wide array of national retailers, supermarkets like ShopRite and Trader Joe's, and chain restaurants. The Staten Island Mall, also on Richmond Avenue, provides comprehensive shopping and dining options all in one location.

For more local flavor and sit-down dining, residents often visit the nearby neighborhoods of New Dorp and Todt Hill. These areas boast a variety of restaurants, from classic Italian eateries and pizzerias to contemporary American bistros and Asian fusion cuisine. The lack of through traffic and commercial activity within Mountain Lakes is a deliberate feature that residents cherish, as they can easily access amenities while returning home to a quiet, undisturbed retreat.

Who Lives Here

Mountain Lakes attracts a demographic that values privacy, space, and natural beauty. The neighborhood is predominantly home to established families, professionals, and empty-nesters who appreciate the suburban quality of life coupled with New York City's resources. The community is tight-knit, with many residents having lived in the area for decades, fostering a strong sense of neighborhood watch and camaraderie. The population is largely middle to upper-middle class, with a high rate of homeownership.

Newcomers are often drawn by the unique combination of architectural character, lot size, and immediate access to wilderness that is difficult to find elsewhere in the five boroughs

Mountain Lakes Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in Mountain Lakes, Staten Island

Nearby Neighborhoods in Staten Island, NY

← Back to all Staten Island, NY real estate agents

← Back to all New York real estate agents