Arlington, Staten Island, NY

Arlington Neighborhood Overview

Overview

Arlington is a historic, residential neighborhood located in northeastern Staten Island, adjacent to the bustling ferry terminal area of St. George. It is bounded roughly by the Kill Van Kull to the north, the Staten Island Railway to the east, and the busy thoroughfares of Victory Boulevard and Forest Avenue to the south and west. The neighborhood's character is defined by its quiet, tree-lined streets, steep hills offering stunning views of the Upper New York Bay and the Manhattan skyline, and a rich architectural heritage that speaks to its 19th-century origins as a summer retreat for wealthy merchants.

Originally developed as part of the village of Edgewater, Arlington boasts one of the largest collections of Victorian architecture in New York City, particularly in the area known as the St. George/Arlington Historic District. The neighborhood's development was spurred by the arrival of the Staten Island Railway and its proximity to the ferry, making it a convenient yet serene escape. Today, Arlington maintains a distinctly residential and somewhat insular feel, offering a peaceful, small-town atmosphere just minutes from the ferry and the borough's civic and cultural hub.

Housing & Real Estate

Arlington's housing stock is dominated by its architectural treasures, including grand, ornate Victorian homes, stately Tudors, and classic American Four-Squares, many meticulously preserved. These historic homes, often perched on hillsides with panoramic water views, represent the upper tier of the local market. The neighborhood also features more modest single-family homes, including Cape Cods and colonials, as well as a smattering of pre-war brick apartment buildings and smaller multi-family homes, particularly on its southern edges.

Real estate prices in Arlington are among the highest on Staten Island, driven by the historic homes, views, and proximity to the ferry. While more affordable options exist away from the prime view blocks, the market is consistently strong. The neighborhood is predominantly owner-occupied, with a high rate of long-term residents who value its historic character. Recent trends show continued interest in restoration and renovation of its classic homes, though new construction is rare and often faces community scrutiny to preserve the area's architectural integrity.

Schools & Education

Arlington is served by New York City's Geographic District 31. The neighborhood itself is home to several well-regarded public schools, including PS 16, the John C. Doody Elementary School, which serves the community. For middle school, students often attend IS 51, the Edwin Markham School, located nearby. Public high school options include the specialized Curtis High School, one of the city's original high schools with a historic campus and diverse academic programs, located just east in St. George.

In addition to public schools, Staten Island's numerous Catholic and private institutions are accessible. Notably, the prestigious Staten Island Academy, the borough's only independent college preparatory school, is located just to the south in neighboring Todt Hill. The presence of the College of Staten Island's Willowbrook campus and St. John's University's Staten Island campus also provides higher education opportunities nearby, contributing to the area's educational landscape.

Parks & Recreation

Arlington is defined by its impressive, sprawling green spaces. The neighborhood is home to the 80-acre Silver Lake Park, a recreational hub featuring a public golf course, tennis courts, running tracks, and the serene Silver Lake itself, which is a reservoir. The park's paths are popular for walking, jogging, and cycling. Just to the south lies the even more expansive Clove Lakes Park, offering over 190 acres of woodlands, streams, and the iconic Clove Lakes, with boating, fishing, and extensive hiking trails.

These interconnected park systems provide Arlington residents with a remarkable amount of accessible outdoor recreation, fostering an active community. The neighborhood's steep, winding streets also double as challenging routes for local runners and cyclists. While Arlington lacks a major community center within its immediate borders, the parks serve as the primary venues for sports, leisure, and family gatherings, deeply integrating nature into daily life.

Local Dining & Shopping

Arlington's commercial life is primarily centered along its main arteries, particularly Forest Avenue and Victory Boulevard. These strips offer a mix of essential services, neighborhood eateries, and small businesses. Dining options tend to be classic and casual, featuring long-standing pizzerias, family-run Italian restaurants, diners, and delis. The area is not known for a high concentration of trendy cafes or fine dining, which reinforces its residential, family-oriented character.

For grocery shopping, residents rely on key local staples like the Food Bazaar supermarket on Victory Boulevard and various smaller ethnic markets and butchers. While day-to-day retail needs are met locally, residents often venture to the nearby Staten Island Mall in New Springville or the revitalized St. George waterfront for broader shopping, entertainment, and more diverse restaurant options. The neighborhood's commercial scene is practical, serving the community without drawing significant outside foot traffic.

Who Lives Here

Arlington attracts a stable, family-oriented population with deep roots in Staten Island. Many residents are long-term homeowners, including multi-generational families who cherish the neighborhood's history, tranquility, and strong sense of community. The demographic skews toward established professionals, municipal workers, and individuals who value space, architectural character, and a slower pace of life while maintaining a manageable commute to Manhattan via the ferry.

The community vibe is quiet, proud, and protective of its historic and environmental assets. Residents are often actively involved in neighborhood associations and preservation efforts. Arlington

Arlington Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in Arlington, Staten Island

5 agents met the full merit gate for Arlington, Staten Island, NY, selected from over 130,000 licensed New York professionals.

Nearby Neighborhoods in Staten Island, NY

← Back to all Staten Island, NY real estate agents

← Back to all New York real estate agents