Top Real Estate Agents in Andrews Settlement, Rochester, New York

Andrews Settlement Neighborhood Market Intelligence

Overview

Andrews Settlement is a quiet, historic neighborhood located in the northeast quadrant of Rochester, New York. It is bounded roughly by Culver Road to the west, Bay Street to the south, and the sprawling campus of St. John Fisher University to the east. The area's character is defined by its deep roots, with many homes dating back to the late 19th and early 20th centuries, and a strong sense of community continuity among its residents.

The neighborhood's history is tied to its original development as a streetcar suburb, offering a pastoral escape from the city center while remaining connected by transit. Its name is derived from the Andrews family, prominent early landowners in the area. Today, it retains a distinctly residential, almost village-like feel within the city limits, characterized by mature tree canopies, winding streets, and a mix of architectural styles that tell the story of its gradual growth over decades.

Housing & Real Estate

The housing stock in Andrews Settlement is predominantly composed of single-family homes, ranging from charming Victorian and Queen Anne styles to sturdy American Foursquares, classic Colonials, and Craftsman bungalows. Lot sizes are generally generous for an in-city neighborhood, contributing to its spacious and green aesthetic. Many properties feature historic details like original woodwork, stained glass, and wide front porches.

Home prices in Andrews Settlement are typically above the city-wide median, reflecting the neighborhood's desirability, historic charm, and proximity to amenities and universities. The market is primarily owner-occupied, with a relatively low rental percentage compared to more student-heavy areas. Recent trends show steady demand, with well-maintained historic homes commanding premium prices, indicating the area's enduring appeal for those seeking character and stability.

Schools & Education

Andrews Settlement is served by the Rochester City School District (RCSD). The designated neighborhood elementary school is often School #41, the Francis Parker School No. 23, known for its committed staff and community involvement. For secondary education, students may attend various district magnet and community schools, offering specialized programs. Families in the area are often highly engaged in their children's education and supportive of local school initiatives.

The neighborhood's educational landscape is significantly shaped by its proximity to several private institutions. The Allendale Columbia School, a highly-regarded Pre-K through 12 independent school, is located just to the south. Furthermore, the presence of St. John Fisher University on its eastern border creates a collegiate atmosphere and provides access to cultural and educational events, though the neighborhood itself remains distinctly separate from typical student housing areas.

Parks & Recreation

Residents enjoy access to several notable green spaces. The sprawling Cobbs Hill Park, with its iconic water reservoir, walking trails, sports fields, and panoramic views of the Rochester skyline, is a short drive or bike ride to the southwest. Closer to home, the neighborhood itself functions as a park-like setting, ideal for walking, jogging, and cycling along its quiet, shaded streets.

For organized recreation, the nearby Genesee Valley Park Sports Complex offers extensive facilities for soccer, lacrosse, and other field sports. The Erie Canal Heritage Trail is also easily accessible, providing miles of paved paths for biking, running, and walking that connect to a wider regional trail network. These amenities support an active, outdoor-oriented lifestyle for individuals and families alike.

Local Dining & Shopping

While primarily residential, Andrews Settlement is conveniently situated near vibrant commercial corridors. Monroe Avenue, a major east-west artery to the south, offers an eclectic mix of restaurants, cafes, and boutique shops. Residents can find everything from casual diners and pizzerias to international cuisine and trendy coffee shops within a short drive. The Park Avenue and University Avenue districts are also within easy reach, expanding dining and nightlife options considerably.

For everyday needs, the neighborhood is served by several nearby grocery options, including a Wegmans on Monroe Avenue and smaller specialty markets. The South Wedge and Swillburg neighborhoods to the west provide additional local business districts with breweries, bakeries, and unique retail stores. This proximity allows Andrews Settlement to maintain its tranquil residential character while ensuring convenience is never far away.

Who Lives Here

Andrews Settlement attracts a mix of long-time Rochester residents, professionals, academics, and families who value historic preservation, architectural integrity, and a strong community fabric. The population tends to be well-educated and stable, with many households residing in the neighborhood for decades. There is a palpable sense of stewardship, with residents actively maintaining their historic properties and engaging in neighborhood associations.

The community vibe is one of quiet pride and neighborliness. It draws individuals seeking the architectural charm and lot sizes often associated with suburbs, but with the cultural benefits and convenience of city living. The presence of both young families and empty-nesters creates a balanced demographic, fostering an environment that is both dynamic and deeply rooted. It is a neighborhood for those who appreciate history, green space, and a tight-knit community atmosphere within Rochester's urban framework.

Nearby Neighborhoods (8)

Data Sources

Top10Lists.us is an independent neighborhood data aggregator. Full methodology