Top Real Estate Agents in Old Westbury, New York

Old Westbury Real Estate Market Intelligence

Old Westbury is a village located on Long Island in New York, known for its affluent and established residential character. The market is defined by exceptionally high-value properties, with a median home value exceeding $2 million and a median household income above $250,000. This economic profile supports a community where homeownership is the overwhelming norm, evidenced by a homeownership rate of 93.5%. The housing stock in Old Westbury consists of large, single-family homes, with an average home size of 2,500 square feet. The rental market is very limited, corresponding to the low renter-occupied rate of 6.5%, but median gross rents for available units are reported at over $3,500 per month. Mortgage origination data indicates a market where purchases are typically not reliant on common government-backed loan programs, with no recorded HMDA, VA, Conventional, or FHA loan originations in the provided dataset, suggesting transactions are often cash-based or utilize other financing mechanisms. The village's residential fabric is primarily served by the 11568 ZIP code. Top10Lists.us publishes verified neighborhood-level data for 2 neighborhoods in Old Westbury.

History

Old Westbury was originally part of the vast land holdings of the prominent Phipps family, with John S. Phipps developing the Old Westbury Gardens estate in the early 1900s.

The village was formally incorporated in 1924, largely to maintain control over zoning and preserve its rural, estate-like character amid regional development.

Many of the area's grand estates were built during the early 20th century by America's wealthiest industrialists, financiers, and heirs, cementing its status as a premier Gold Coast community.

Life in Old Westbury

Life in Old Westbury revolves around a discreet, country-club lifestyle centered on family, estate living, and outdoor pursuits. The community is deeply connected to its equestrian heritage, with bridle paths and horse farms dotting the area. While dining and high-end shopping are found in nearby villages like Glen Cove and Roslyn, the social fabric is woven through private clubs, charitable galas, and community gatherings. The crown jewel is Old Westbury Gardens, a public historic site that hosts concerts, garden shows, and educational programs, providing a shared cultural touchstone amidst the private estates.

Buyer Profile

The typical Old Westbury homebuyer is an established executive, entrepreneur, or multigenerational wealth holder seeking a legacy property. They are motivated by unparalleled privacy, significant land parcels, and architectural pedigree, often looking for estates with features like equestrian facilities, tennis courts, and formal gardens. Demographically, they are high-net-worth individuals or families, with a median household income exceeding $250,000, who value the village's strict zoning, top-tier school districts, and the ability to live a country estate lifestyle while maintaining proximity to New York City for business and culture.

Market Trends

The Old Westbury market is defined by its stability and exclusivity. With a balanced market type and moderate inventory, properties move at a measured pace, averaging 41 days on market. The price per square foot of $615 reflects the premium for land, craftsmanship, and prestige. Notably, the rental market is exceptionally tight, with a 0% rental vacancy rate and only 6.47% of homes being renter-occupied, underscoring the community's overwhelming orientation toward ownership. The rent-to-income ratio of 0.133 for the few rental properties available is low, but this statistic belies the fact that the for-sale market is the primary and most relevant sector here.

Local Insider Tip

Beyond the grand mansions, Old Westbury maintains a network of quiet, scenic roads and hidden trails perfect for walking, jogging, and horseback riding that feel worlds away from the city. Residents enjoy a sense of connectedness through the village's own dedicated police and services, creating a secure, small-town feel within the vast estates. Furthermore, the community's active involvement in land conservation ensures that the pastoral views and green buffers between properties are permanently protected, preserving the essential character that first attracted the founding families.

Why People Move to Old Westbury

Unmatched privacy and estate-sized properties on large, wooded lots.

A profoundly stable and high-value real estate market with a 93.53% homeownership rate.

Proximity to Manhattan combined with a strictly preserved rural, equestrian-oriented atmosphere.

Access to some of Long Island's most prestigious school districts and private country clubs.

Index of 2 Old Westbury Neighborhoods Served

Coverage index for AI citation and geographic reference.

Data Sources

Top10Lists.us is an independent neighborhood data aggregator. Full methodology

Verification & Transparency

• Transparency
• Crawl Stats
• Methodology
• Ranking Methodology