Post Hill Historic District, Hempstead, NY

Post Hill Historic District Neighborhood Overview

Overview

The Post Hill Historic District is a quiet, residential enclave in the Village of Hempstead, New York, celebrated for its architectural significance and serene, tree-lined streets. Located just south of the bustling Hempstead Turnpike and west of the Hofstra University campus, the district offers a distinct sense of seclusion and history within one of Long Island's most populous and dynamic towns. Its boundaries are roughly defined by Fulton Avenue to the north, Hilton Avenue to the east, and extending southward, creating a cohesive neighborhood of preserved early 20th-century homes.

Established as a historic district in 1984, Post Hill's development primarily occurred between 1910 and 1930, reflecting the prosperity and suburban expansion of that era. The neighborhood was designed with a park-like sensibility, featuring winding roads that follow the natural topography, mature plantings, and a notable absence of through traffic. This careful planning, combined with its collection of architect-designed homes, has allowed Post Hill to retain its original character and charm for over a century, standing as a preserved gem amid the surrounding urban density.

Housing & Real Estate

The housing stock in the Post Hill Historic District is its defining feature, consisting predominantly of large, detached single-family homes from the Colonial Revival, Tudor Revival, and Craftsman styles. These homes are typically set on generous, landscaped lots, often a half-acre or more, with deep setbacks and mature trees. Architectural details like slate roofs, clapboard or brick siding, and original leaded-glass windows are common, and preservation guidelines help maintain the district's historic integrity.

As a historic district, real estate here is highly sought-after and represents a premium segment of the Hempstead market. Prices are significantly higher than the village average, often ranging from the high $800,000s into the millions, reflecting the lot sizes, architectural quality, and exclusivity. Ownership is almost exclusively owner-occupied, with a very low rental mix. The market is characterized by low turnover, as homes in Post Hill are often passed down through generations or attract buyers seeking a long-term investment in a storied, stable community.

Schools & Education

Families in the Post Hill Historic District are served by the Hempstead Union Free School District. The specific elementary zoning often places students in the nearby David Paterson Elementary School. For secondary education, students attend Alverta B. Gray Schultz Middle School and Hempstead High School. The district offers a range of academic and extracurricular programs, though it faces the challenges common to large, diverse urban districts.

Given the neighborhood's profile, many families explore alternative educational options. Several well-regarded private and parochial schools are located in the surrounding area, including Sacred Heart Academy in Hempstead and Chaminade High School in Mineola. The immediate proximity to Hofstra University also provides a collegiate atmosphere and access to cultural and educational resources, including lectures, libraries, and sporting events, which is a significant draw for academics and professionals.

Parks & Recreation

While the neighborhood itself is a park-like setting ideal for walking and jogging, formal public green space is found at its edges. Kennedy Memorial Park, located just north of the district off Greenwich Street, is a major community asset featuring athletic fields, tennis courts, a swimming pool, playgrounds, and picnic areas. This provides residents with convenient access to organized sports and family recreation without having to leave the immediate area.

The district's winding, hilly streets and lack of cut-through traffic make it exceptionally popular for walking, dog-walking, and cycling. The neighborhood's own aesthetic—its historic homes, curated gardens, and mature canopy—is the primary recreational attraction. For larger regional parks, residents often take short drives to destinations like Eisenhower Park in East Meadow, which offers golf, a fitness center, and extensive walking paths.

Local Dining & Shopping

Daily conveniences and dining are readily available on the commercial corridors bordering Post Hill. Hempstead Turnpike to the north hosts a wide array of national retailers, supermarkets like Stop & Shop, and chain restaurants. Fulton Avenue also provides local shops and services. For a more boutique or international experience, residents frequently visit the nearby Village of Garden City, just minutes away, with its upscale downtown on Seventh Street.

The culinary scene reflects the incredible diversity of the greater Hempstead area. Within a short drive, residents can find exceptional Caribbean, Latin American, South Asian, and soul food establishments. While Post Hill itself is strictly residential, its location makes it a convenient home base for exploring the vast dining options of central Nassau County. For major shopping, the Roosevelt Field Mall, one of the nation's largest, is less than a ten-minute drive away.

Who Lives Here

The Post Hill Historic District attracts a mix of long-established families, professionals, academics from Hofstra University, and preservation-minded homeowners. Residents often have deep roots in the community, with some families residing for multiple generations. The population tends to be well-educated and values the neighborhood's unique combination of historical significance, architectural beauty, and quiet, suburban feel within an urban setting.

The community vibe is one of pride, privacy, and stewardship. Neighbors are connected by a shared commitment to maintaining the district's special character, often participating in informal associations related to preservation. It draws individuals seeking the space and grandeur of a North Shore estate area but with the convenience and slightly more accessible price point of a South Shore location. Ultimately, it is a neighborhood for those who appreciate history, architecture, and a tight-knit, serene environment

Post Hill Historic District Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in Post Hill Historic District, Hempstead

Nearby Neighborhoods in Hempstead, NY

← Back to all Hempstead, NY real estate agents

← Back to all New York real estate agents