Fishers Island, Hempstead, NY

Fishers Island Neighborhood Overview

Overview

Fishers Island is a distinct and historic neighborhood located within the Town of Hempstead in Nassau County, New York. It is situated on a narrow strip of land between the Meadowbrook State Parkway and the waters of Milburn Creek and the Bay Park Sewage Treatment Plant's containment ponds. Despite its name, it is not a true island but a peninsula, offering a unique sense of separation and quiet within the densely populated South Shore of Long Island.

The neighborhood's history is deeply tied to the water and early 20th-century development. It was originally part of a larger estate and later developed with modest homes, many of which were built for workers at the nearby Roosevelt Field airfield and other local industries. Today, Fishers Island retains a tightly-knit, residential character, known for its quiet, tree-lined streets and a strong sense of community among its residents, who appreciate its seclusion and proximity to major parkways.

Housing & Real Estate

The housing stock in Fishers Island is primarily composed of single-family homes built in the mid-20th century, ranging from compact Cape Cods and ranches to larger split-level and colonial-style houses. Lot sizes are generally modest but well-maintained, with many homes featuring updates and renovations. The architectural style is quintessential post-war Long Island suburbia, reflecting the area's development boom during that era.

Real estate prices in Fishers Island are typically more accessible than in many other Nassau County neighborhoods, making it an attractive entry point for first-time homebuyers and young families looking to establish roots in the area. The market is predominantly owner-occupied, with a very low percentage of rental properties. Recent trends show steady demand due to the neighborhood's affordability relative to the region, its convenient location, and the ongoing appeal of its quiet, family-oriented environment.

Schools & Education

Fishers Island is served by the Uniondale Union Free School District. Students typically attend the district's elementary, middle, and high schools, which are a short drive from the neighborhood. Uniondale High School offers a range of academic programs, Advanced Placement courses, and extracurricular activities. The district is diverse and works to meet the needs of its student population with various educational initiatives.

For private and parochial education, families have several options in the surrounding towns, including schools in East Meadow, Hempstead, and Rockville Centre. Higher education institutions are also within reach, with Nassau Community College in Garden City and Hofstra University in Hempstead located just a few miles away, providing accessible opportunities for continuing education.

Parks & Recreation

While Fishers Island itself is primarily residential, it is surrounded by significant recreational waterways and is minutes from major regional parks. The neighborhood's western border is Milburn Creek, which is popular for kayaking and canoeing. To the east, the Bay Park Conservation Area and the connected ponds offer trails and birdwatching opportunities, adding a natural buffer and green space.

A short drive provides access to some of Long Island's premier beaches and parks. Jones Beach State Park, with its iconic boardwalk, ocean swimming, and concert venue, is approximately a 15-minute drive south. Eisenhower Park in East Meadow, one of the largest public parks in the country, is also nearby, offering golf courses, sports fields, playgrounds, and picnic areas for family outings and athletic activities.

Local Dining & Shopping

Fishers Island residents rely on the commercial corridors of neighboring communities for daily needs and dining. The main retail hub is along Hempstead Turnpike in East Meadow, which features large national retailers, supermarkets like Stop & Shop and ShopRite, and a variety of chain restaurants. The Green Acres Mall in Valley Stream is also a major regional shopping destination within a short drive.

For local dining, the area offers a diverse mix of casual eateries, pizzerias, and ethnic cuisines, including Italian, Chinese, and Latin American restaurants scattered throughout East Meadow and Uniondale. While the neighborhood itself is quiet and residential, the convenience of having substantial shopping and dining options just minutes away by car is a significant perk for those living in Fishers Island.

Who Lives Here

Fishers Island attracts a mix of working-class and middle-class families, many of whom are first-time homebuyers or long-term residents who have raised their children in the neighborhood. The community is known for its down-to-earth, friendly vibe where neighbors often know each other. It has a stable, residential feel, with a population that values the affordability and quiet streets it offers within Nassau County.

The neighborhood is particularly appealing to those who work in the broader Hempstead area, at nearby hospitals, or in trades and services, and who prioritize a short commute and a strong sense of community over bustling commercial activity. It is a neighborhood where residents enjoy the suburban lifestyle with direct access to Long Island's parkways, making trips to beaches, parks, and New York City manageable, while returning home to a peaceful, unpretentious retreat.

Fishers Island Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in Fishers Island, Hempstead

Nearby Neighborhoods in Hempstead, NY

← Back to all Hempstead, NY real estate agents

← Back to all New York real estate agents