Amityville, Hempstead, NY

Amityville Neighborhood Overview

Overview

Amityville is a historic and distinctive village located within the Town of Hempstead on the South Shore of Long Island, New York. Incorporated in 1894, it is famously situated on the border between Nassau and Suffolk counties, with its Main Street serving as the dividing line. The village is best known for its charming, walkable downtown centered on Broadway and Merrick Road, featuring a mix of Victorian architecture, waterfront views, and a vibrant community spirit that sets it apart from surrounding suburban areas.

The neighborhood's character is deeply rooted in its maritime history along the Great South Bay, which has evolved from a center for shipbuilding and oystering into a popular destination for boating and waterfront dining. While Amityville gained international notoriety due to the 1979 film "The Amityville Horror," the reality is a tight-knit, diverse community that actively celebrates its heritage through events, historic preservation, and a strong sense of local pride. Its location offers a semi-urban village feel with the broader amenities of Long Island within easy reach.

Housing & Real Estate

Amityville's housing stock is notably diverse, ranging from historic Victorian homes in the village core, including designated landmarks, to mid-century ranches, Cape Cods, and colonial-style houses in the surrounding neighborhoods. Waterfront properties along the canals and the Great South Bay command premium prices and offer private docks. The overall aesthetic is more varied and architecturally interesting than many typical Long Island suburbs, contributing to its unique appeal.

The real estate market in Amityville offers a relatively more affordable entry point into Nassau County compared to its northern neighbors, though prices have risen steadily. The mix includes single-family homes, some multi-family dwellings, and a limited number of apartment complexes. The market attracts a blend of first-time homebuyers, families seeking a community-oriented village, and those drawn to the nautical lifestyle. Recent trends show continued demand for updated historic homes and renovated properties close to the downtown amenities.

Schools & Education

Amityville is served by the Amityville Union Free School District, which encompasses the village and parts of neighboring Copiague and North Amityville. The district operates several schools, including Amityville Memorial High School. The district has focused on improvement and community engagement, offering various academic and extracurricular programs to serve its diverse student population.

In addition to the public school system, there are several private and parochial school options in the surrounding area, including St. Martin of Tours School. For higher education, nearby institutions include Suffolk County Community College, Farmingdale State College, and Hofstra University, all within a reasonable commuting distance. The community places a strong emphasis on educational support and youth activities through the local library and community centers.

Parks & Recreation

Amityville provides several green spaces and recreational facilities for residents. The 20-acre Amityville Beach and Park on the Great South Bay is a central hub, featuring a public beach, playground, picnic areas, and sports fields, with stunning sunset views. Nearby, the 30-acre Denmark Park offers walking trails, a dog run, and open fields for passive recreation, while the smaller Southards Pond Park provides a picturesque setting with a pond and walking path.

Water-based recreation is a major draw, with multiple marinas, boat launches, and the Amityville Yacht Club facilitating access to the bay and ocean. The village's Department of Parks and Recreation organizes numerous programs, sports leagues, and community events throughout the year. For golf enthusiasts, the historic Venetian Shores Golf Course is located just east of the village, offering a public nine-hole course with waterfront vistas.

Local Dining & Shopping

Amityville's downtown along Broadway is the heart of its dining and shopping scene, characterized by independent businesses and a lack of large chain stores. The restaurant offerings are eclectic, ranging from casual pubs and pizzerias to upscale waterfront dining at establishments like the historic Toast Coffeehouse and the popular Harbor Crab Co. The area also features a variety of cuisines, including Italian, Mexican, and American fare, alongside cozy cafes and bakeries.

For shopping, residents find a mix of boutique clothing stores, antique shops, gift stores, and specialty retailers along the main avenues. Essential grocery needs are met by a Key Food supermarket in the village center, with larger chain supermarkets like Stop & Shop and ShopRite located just outside village boundaries in neighboring Copiague and Massapequa. The village supports a "Shop Local" ethos, with seasonal street fairs and events designed to draw visitors to its unique commercial district.

Who Lives Here

Amityville is home to a diverse population that includes multigenerational families, young professionals, artists, and maritime enthusiasts. The community has a strong blue-collar heritage alongside a growing number of creative professionals attracted by the village's character and relative affordability. There is a palpable sense of local pride and neighborliness, with many residents actively involved in community organizations, historic preservation, and village events.

The demographic is a blend of cultures and backgrounds, contributing to a vibrant and inclusive community vibe. People are drawn to Amityville for its unique identity—a walkable, historic village with waterfront access that avoids the homogenized feel of some suburban tracts. It appeals to those seeking a strong sense of place, community connection, and a lifestyle that balances suburban comfort with the cultural and recreational amenities of a small, self-contained town.

Amityville Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in Amityville, Hempstead

Nearby Neighborhoods in Hempstead, NY

← Back to all Hempstead, NY real estate agents

← Back to all New York real estate agents