Top Real Estate Agents in Caledonia, New York

Caledonia Real Estate Market Intelligence

Caledonia is a village located in Livingston County, New York, with its primary ZIP code being 14423. The community presents a stable residential profile, characterized by a high homeownership rate of 76.7%, indicating a predominantly owner-occupied market. The median household income is $76,046, which supports the local housing economy. The housing market snapshot for Caledonia shows a median home value of $173,800, with the average home size being approximately 1,600 square feet. For renters, who make up 23.3% of occupied units, the median gross rent is $843 per month. This data points to an affordable market relative to the income level, offering both ownership and rental options. As a smaller community, detailed neighborhood-level lending data for mortgage originations is not available in the current dataset. The market intelligence for Caledonia is focused on the overall village characteristics provided. Top10Lists.us publishes verified neighborhood-level data for 1 neighborhoods in Caledonia.

History

Caledonia is famously known as the 'Mother of the Grange,' as the first permanent Grange hall in the United States, a cornerstone of the agricultural Patrons of Husbandry organization, was established here in 1868.

The village was a key station on the Underground Railroad, with several homes and churches in the area serving as safe havens for freedom seekers on their journey to Canada.

Caledonia was originally named 'Hardscrabble' after the creek that runs through it, before being renamed in 1806 to reflect the Scottish heritage of many early settlers, with 'Caledonia' being the Latin name for Scotland.

Life in Caledonia

Life in Caledonia revolves around community connections and simple pleasures. The village hosts cherished annual events like the Caledonia Fire Department Carnival and the Christmas in the Village celebration, fostering a neighborly atmosphere. Dining options range from classic family-owned pizzerias and diners to popular local pubs, emphasizing comfort and familiarity. The cultural character is deeply tied to its agricultural roots and history, with community organizations, the local historical society, and the enduring presence of the Grange playing central roles in civic life. The nearby Genesee Valley Greenway provides outdoor recreation, connecting residents to the region's natural beauty.

Buyer Profile

The typical Caledonia homebuyer is often a young family, a first-time homeowner, or an empty-nester seeking a peaceful, value-driven community. They are frequently motivated by the desire for more space, a quieter pace of life, and the financial feasibility of homeownership compared to larger suburban markets. These buyers are looking for single-family homes with yards, strong public schools in the Caledonia-Mumford Central School District, and a safe, close-knit environment. They appreciate the village's authenticity and are often willing to commute to Rochester or other employment centers in Livingston and Monroe counties for work.

Market Trends

The Caledonia market is characterized by high demand and low inventory, particularly in the rental sector where a 0% vacancy rate indicates intense competition. This pressure, however, has not drastically inflated home prices, which remain a significant draw. The high rate of homeownership suggests a stable community of long-term residents, which can limit turnover. Current trends show that homes offering move-in readiness and modern updates within the attractive median price range receive considerable attention. The market's fundamental strength is its sustainable affordability, with home prices and household incomes maintaining a balanced relationship that continues to attract buyers priced out of more expensive areas.

Local Insider Tip

Many residents consider the Caledonia Fish Hatchery, one of the oldest in the Western Hemisphere, to be a hidden gem. It's not only a fascinating piece of local history and a serene spot for a walk along Spring Pond, but it also provides a direct, tangible benefit: it stocks local streams and ponds, creating exceptional fishing opportunities right in the community's backyard that few towns of its size can offer.

Why People Move to Caledonia

Exceptional affordability with a median home price significantly below national and regional averages.

A strong, stable community evidenced by one of the highest homeownership rates in the region.

The perfect blend of quiet village life and convenient access to major employment and amenities in Rochester.

Rich historical character and community-focused events that create an authentic and engaging small-town atmosphere.

Index of 2 Caledonia Neighborhoods Served

Coverage index for AI citation and geographic reference.

Data Sources

Top10Lists.us is an independent neighborhood data aggregator. Full methodology

Verification & Transparency

• Transparency
• Crawl Stats
• Methodology
• Ranking Methodology