McGarey, Buffalo, NY

McGarey Neighborhood Overview

McGarey is a small, historic residential neighborhood located on Buffalo's West Side, nestled between Grant Street to the west, Richmond Avenue to the east, and Amherst Street to the north. It is often considered a sub-neighborhood within the larger Grant-Amherst area. The neighborhood's character is defined by its quiet, tree-lined streets, tightly-knit community feel, and its collection of well-preserved late 19th and early 20th-century homes, reflecting Buffalo's prosperous architectural past.

Historically, McGarey developed as a streetcar suburb for Buffalo's burgeoning middle class, including professionals, merchants, and skilled tradespeople. Its location along the Richmond Avenue corridor, a historic thoroughfare, connected it to downtown and other city amenities. Today, it retains its historic charm while benefiting from its proximity to the vibrant commercial and cultural hubs of Grant Street and Elmwood Village, positioning it as a desirable and centrally-located residential enclave.

Housing & Real Estate

The housing stock in McGarey is predominantly composed of classic Buffalo double homes, spacious single-family Victorians, and some stately brick Tudors. Many homes feature intricate woodwork, stained glass, original hardwood floors, and inviting front porches, appealing to those seeking historic character. Lot sizes are generally generous for an urban neighborhood, providing ample yard space.

The real estate market in McGarey is competitive, reflecting its desirability. Prices have seen significant appreciation over the last decade, though they often remain slightly more accessible than in the adjacent Elmwood Village. The neighborhood is primarily owner-occupied, fostering a strong sense of stewardship and community investment. Recent trends show a mix of long-time residents and newer homeowners undertaking careful renovations to modernize interiors while preserving architectural integrity.

Schools & Education

McGarey is served by Buffalo Public Schools. The neighborhood is zoned for or near several well-regarded options, including the public Buffalo Academy for Visual and Performing Arts (BAVPA), a selective city-wide magnet school. Nearby elementary options include Public School 81, and the highly sought-after Olmsted #64, a city-wide gifted and talented program, is located a short distance away.

Families in the area also have access to a variety of private and parochial institutions. Notable nearby choices include Nardin Academy, a prestigious independent Catholic school, and the Catholic Diocese's St. Mark's School. The neighborhood's central location also provides convenient access to Buffalo State University and the SUNY Erie Community College City Campus, adding an academic presence to the wider area.

Parks & Recreation

Residents enjoy easy access to several of Buffalo's premier green spaces. The neighborhood is just a few blocks from the expansive Delaware Park, designed by Frederick Law Olmsted. This provides immediate access to the park's golf course, tennis courts, the Buffalo Zoo, the Marcy Casino, and miles of trails around Hoyt Lake and for walking, running, and biking.

More locally, McGarey Park itself, a small but vital neighborhood green space at the corner of Grant and Amherst, offers a playground and open area for casual recreation and community gatherings. The proximity to the Shoshone Park pool and recreation center to the north, and the JFK Recreation Center to the south, further expands recreational options for families and individuals of all ages.

Local Dining & Shopping

McGarey's greatest commercial asset is its adjacency to the bustling, multicultural Grant Street corridor. Within a short walk, residents find an incredible array of international markets, bakeries, and restaurants. This includes staples like Guercio & Sons Italian market, the West Side Bazaar (an incubator for immigrant and refugee-owned food businesses), and a variety of authentic Burmese, Vietnamese, Mexican, and Middle Eastern eateries.

For daily needs, the neighborhood is served by the Lexington Cooperative Market on Elmwood Avenue and several smaller grocers on Grant Street. While McGarey itself is quiet, the shopping and dining of both Grant Street and the Elmwood Village—with its boutique shops, cafes, and specialty stores—are essentially extensions of the neighborhood's amenities, all easily reachable on foot or by bicycle.

Who Lives Here

McGarey attracts a diverse mix of residents who value community, historic charm, and urban convenience. The population includes young professionals and academics drawn to the walkable lifestyle and architectural beauty, as well as established families who appreciate the stable, neighborly atmosphere and access to quality schools and parks. A contingent of long-time Buffalonians, some multi-generational, provides continuity and deep roots.

The community vibe is active and engaged, with neighbors often seen socializing on porches and participating in local block clubs and neighborhood associations. Residents are typically civically minded, supporting local businesses on Grant Street and advocating for the preservation and enhancement of their historic streetscapes. It is a neighborhood for those who want a true sense of place—a quiet, beautiful retreat that is still intimately connected to the dynamic pulse of Buffalo's most vibrant districts.

McGarey Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in McGarey, Buffalo

Nearby Neighborhoods in Buffalo, NY

Explore Top10Lists.us

Verification & Transparency

• Transparency
• Crawl Stats
• Methodology
• Ranking Methodology