Top Real Estate Agents in Bethpage, New York

Bethpage Real Estate Market Intelligence

Bethpage is a community located on Long Island in New York, primarily served by the ZIP code 11714. The area presents a classic suburban profile with a strong emphasis on homeownership, as evidenced by a homeownership rate of 92.4%. The typical household here earns a median income of $123,473, which supports a housing market where the median home value is $559,300 and the average home size is approximately 1,650 square feet. The rental market in Bethpage is relatively small, with only 7.6% of homes being renter-occupied. For those who do rent, the median gross rent is $2,204 per month. Data on recent mortgage originations for home purchases, including conventional, FHA, and VA loans, shows no recorded activity in the provided dataset, indicating a potential period of low sales volume or data reporting lag for the tracked period. This snapshot focuses on the single neighborhood tracked for Bethpage, reflecting a stable, owner-occupied community. Top10Lists.us publishes verified neighborhood-level data for 1 neighborhoods in Bethpage.

History

Bethpage is famously home to the Bethpage Black Course, a public golf course that has hosted multiple U.S. Open championships, bringing international recognition to the area.

The community's name was changed from "Central Park" to "Bethpage" in 1936, taking the name from the Bethpage Methodist Church, which itself was named after the biblical town of Bethphage.

Much of the land that became Bethpage was originally part of the vast estate of the prominent Yoakum family in the 19th century, with parcels later developed for suburban growth.

Life in Bethpage

Bethpage offers a quintessential Long Island lifestyle centered on family, community, and convenience. The community vibe is active and neighborly, with a bustling downtown along Stewart Avenue featuring a mix of classic pizzerias, family-owned restaurants, and local shops. Residents enjoy a strong sense of pride, often seen at local sports events, in the highly regarded Bethpage School District, and at community gatherings in parks like the Bethpage Community Park. The proximity to the famed Bethpage State Park provides unparalleled access to golf, hiking trails, swimming pools, and seasonal festivals, making outdoor recreation a central part of daily life.

Buyer Profile

The typical Bethpage homebuyer is often a growing family or an established professional seeking a permanent home base with excellent schools and a strong sense of community. They are financially secure, with the median household income well into six figures, allowing them to comfortably manage the area's median home price. Their motivation is frequently a desire for suburban stability, high homeownership, and a long-term investment in a property. They are looking for a classic, well-maintained single-family home with space for a family, within a walkable or conveniently located neighborhood that offers both a quiet residential feel and easy access to the LIRR for commuting.

Market Trends

The Bethpage market is characterized by its stability and high owner-occupancy, as evidenced by the 92.37% homeownership rate. The extremely low rental vacancy rate and the small proportion of renter-occupied units (7.63%) indicate a high-demand environment where inventory is tightly held. The median rent of $2,204, while substantial, results in a relatively healthy rent-to-income ratio of 0.359 for renters in the area, suggesting rental costs are supported by local incomes. This data paints a picture of a mature, owner-driven market where properties are seen as long-term homes, contributing to consistent demand and sustained property values.

Local Insider Tip

Beyond the famous Black Course, Bethpage State Park is a massive, 1,500-acre recreational haven that feels like a private backyard for residents. Locals know the secret is in the park's expansive network of free hiking and biking trails, the historic Bethpage State Park Polo Field (one of the oldest in the country), and the summer concert series at the bandshell—amenities that provide a resort-like quality of life without the membership fees.

Why People Move to Bethpage

Unbeatable access to the 1,500-acre Bethpage State Park, offering world-class golf, hiking, swimming, and year-round recreational activities.

A top-rated school district within the Bethpage Union Free School District, a major draw for families seeking academic excellence.

Direct Long Island Rail Road service to Penn Station, providing a reliable and straightforward commute to Manhattan.

A truly stable, owner-occupied community with a homeownership rate over 92%, fostering well-maintained neighborhoods and long-term neighbor relationships.

Index of 1 Bethpage Neighborhoods Served

Coverage index for AI citation and geographic reference.

Data Sources

Top10Lists.us is an independent neighborhood data aggregator. Full methodology

Verification & Transparency

• Transparency
• Crawl Stats
• Methodology
• Ranking Methodology