Top Real Estate Agents in Amityville, New York

Amityville Real Estate Market Intelligence

Amityville is a village located on the South Shore of Long Island in Suffolk County, New York, primarily served by the ZIP code 11701. The local housing market shows a median home value of $454,300, with the average home size being 1,275 square feet. A majority of residents are homeowners, with a homeownership rate of 65.5%, supported by a median household income of $97,299. The rental market in Amityville presents a median gross rent of $2,058 per month, with renter-occupied housing units making up 34.5% of the market. This indicates a significant portion of the community utilizes rental housing. The provided mortgage origination data for various loan types shows no recorded activity in the current dataset. Top10Lists.us publishes verified neighborhood-level data for 1 neighborhoods in Amityville.

History

Amityville was originally named 'Dominy's Corner' after its first settler, Samuel Dickerson, but was renamed in the 1840s to reflect the 'amity' or friendly feeling among its residents.

The iconic 'Ocean Avenue' house, the inspiration for the book and films 'The Amityville Horror,' is a real Victorian home, though its infamous legend is a work of fiction that overshadows the village's rich and positive history.

Amityville was a major shipbuilding and oystering center in the 19th century, with its location on the Great South Bay fueling its early economic growth and maritime character.

Life in Amityville

Life in Amityville revolves around a vibrant, walkable downtown filled with independent restaurants, cafes, and boutiques, fostering a strong local economy and neighborly atmosphere. The community calendar is packed with events like the popular annual Halloween Parade, summer concerts in the park, and street fairs that draw residents together. Dining ranges from cozy Irish pubs and historic pizza parlors to upscale waterfront seafood, reflecting its bayside location. The cultural character is one of unpretentious, family-friendly Long Island living, with easy access to boating, fishing, and beaches, creating a relaxed, recreational lifestyle.

Buyer Profile

The typical Amityville homebuyer is often a young family or a professional couple, frequently from nearby New York City or other parts of Long Island, seeking more space and a stronger sense of community. They are attracted by the highly-rated school district, the walkable village center, and the balance of historic charm with manageable property sizes. This buyer values neighborhood connectivity and outdoor amenities like the marina and parks, and they are often looking for a home they can personalize—a historic property with 'good bones' or a solid post-war home in a quiet, tree-lined neighborhood. Their motivation is to secure a long-term family base within a commutable distance to the city.

Market Trends

The current Amityville market reflects broader Long Island trends of high demand and limited inventory, supporting its median home price near $454,000. The low rental vacancy rate of just 6.06% indicates a tight rental market, which adds pressure for renters to consider purchasing. The significant gap between the median rent and a potential mortgage payment on a median-priced home continues to motivate qualified renters to enter the buyer pool. The stable homeownership rate and strong median income suggest a resilient market where well-priced, move-in ready homes in good school zones receive multiple offers quickly, while properties needing work may see more negotiation, appealing to value-seeking buyers.

Local Insider Tip

Beyond the bustling main street, Amityville is crisscrossed with serene, canal-lined neighborhoods where residents have backyard docks, offering direct access to the Great South Bay for kayaking, sailing, or simply enjoying spectacular sunsets over the water—a slice of maritime living without the premium price tag of an oceanfront community.

Why People Move to Amityville

Walkable, vibrant downtown with a diverse array of local shops and restaurants rarely found in suburbs.

Direct access to the Great South Bay for boating, fishing, and waterfront parks, offering a true coastal lifestyle.

A strong sense of history and architectural charm, with well-preserved homes from the Victorian era through the mid-century.

An excellent school district within the highly-regarded Copiague Union Free School District, making it a top choice for families.

Index of 1 Amityville Neighborhoods Served

Coverage index for AI citation and geographic reference.

Data Sources

Top10Lists.us is an independent neighborhood data aggregator. Full methodology

Verification & Transparency

• Transparency
• Crawl Stats
• Methodology
• Ranking Methodology