Top Real Estate Agents in Amagansett, New York

Amagansett Real Estate Market Intelligence

Amagansett, located on the eastern end of Long Island in New York, is a prestigious hamlet within the Town of East Hampton. The community is primarily served by the ZIP code 11930. The local housing market is characterized by significant property values, with a median home value of $1,842,500, reflecting its status as a high-end destination. Homes here have an average size of approximately 1,700 square feet. The market is overwhelmingly dominated by homeowners, with a homeownership rate of 88.1% compared to a renter-occupied rate of just 11.9%. This aligns with the substantial median household income of $139,917, which supports the area's premium real estate. Data shows no recorded mortgage originations for government-backed or conventional loans in the most recent period, indicating a market where purchases may frequently be made with cash or alternative financing. This snapshot covers the core residential area of Amagansett. Top10Lists.us publishes verified neighborhood-level data for 1 neighborhoods in Amagansett.

History

The name Amagansett is derived from the Montaukett Native American word 'Amagansett,' meaning 'place of good water,' a reference to the fresh water found in its dunes.

In 1942, four Nazi saboteurs from Operation Pastorius came ashore at Atlantic Avenue Beach in Amagansett, leading to a major FBI investigation and the eventual execution of six of the eight men involved.

The historic Amagansett Square, with buildings dating to the 17th and 18th centuries, was once a central hub for the whaling and fishing industries, and the iconic Amagansett Farmers Market building originally served as a Presbyterian church built in 1725.

Life in Amagansett

Amagansett's culture is elegantly casual, centered around its stunning natural assets and a tight-knit community feel. Life revolves around the ocean, with surfing, beachcombing, and sunset gatherings at Indian Wells Beach or Atlantic Beach. The hamlet fosters a strong local scene with beloved institutions like the Amagansett Farmers Market, the Amagansett Library, and the Stephen Talkhouse for live music. Dining ranges from the iconic lobster roll at Lunch and the sophisticated cuisine of The Meeting House to casual farm-stand fare. Community events, from the Amagansett Historical Association's talks to summer art shows, reinforce a sense of place that values preservation and understated enjoyment.

Buyer Profile

The typical Amagansett homebuyer is often a high-net-worth individual or family, drawn from New York City and other major metropolitan areas, with a median household income well into the six figures. They are frequently seeking a primary residence for a quieter life or a secondary home for weekend and summer retreats. This buyer values privacy, natural beauty, and architectural quality over ostentatious displays of wealth. They are looking for a property that offers a seamless indoor-outdoor lifestyle, whether a modern farmhouse, a renovated classic, or a new construction with proximity to the ocean or farm fields. Their motivation is a blend of investment in a stable, high-demand market and a deep appreciation for Amagansett's preserved, community-oriented character.

Market Trends

The current Amagansett market is characterized by extremely low inventory and high demand, creating a competitive environment for buyers. The median home price of $1,842,500 reflects steady appreciation, driven by the limited supply of homes and the hamlet's enduring appeal. The complete absence of rental vacancies (0.0%) and the minimal renter-occupied segment (11.9%) highlight the intense pressure in both the ownership and rental sectors, suggesting that any available property, whether for sale or seasonal lease, moves quickly. This trend underscores Amagansett's status as a 'hold' market, where properties are rarely sold and homeownership is a long-term commitment, further insulating values and contributing to the community's stability.

Local Insider Tip

Beyond the famed ocean beaches, Amagansett offers immediate access to the hidden gem of Napeague Harbor, a serene bay perfect for paddleboarding, kayaking, and clamming. Locals know that the stretch of Napeague, often called 'the break,' between Amagansett and Montauk, contains some of the most unique and peaceful landscapes on the East End, including the walking trails through the Hither Woods Preserve and the quiet, bayside dunes, offering a completely different, tranquil waterside experience just minutes from the Atlantic surf.

Why People Move to Amagansett

Direct access to world-class, less-crowded ocean beaches with dedicated resident parking permits.

A strong sense of community and historic preservation with an exceptionally high 88% homeownership rate.

The perfect balance of Hamptons prestige and a low-key, village-centered, year-round lifestyle.

Proximity to premium farmland for fresh local produce and stunning pastoral views that define the area's rustic elegance.

Index of 1 Amagansett Neighborhoods Served

Coverage index for AI citation and geographic reference.

Data Sources

Top10Lists.us is an independent neighborhood data aggregator. Full methodology

Verification & Transparency

• Transparency
• Crawl Stats
• Methodology
• Ranking Methodology