Myrtle Island, Tybee Island, GA

Myrtle Island Neighborhood Overview

Overview

Myrtle Island is a serene and picturesque residential enclave located on the northern tip of Tybee Island, Georgia. Situated between the Atlantic Ocean and the Back River, this neighborhood is defined by its lush maritime forest, winding tidal creeks, and a distinct sense of peaceful seclusion, while remaining just a short drive or bike ride from Tybee's bustling commercial center and iconic pier. The area's history is intertwined with Tybee's broader narrative, evolving from a quiet coastal outpost to a cherished residential community, with many properties enjoying direct water access or serene marsh views.

The character of Myrtle Island is one of relaxed, low-key coastal living. Unlike the more densely developed southern end of Tybee, Myrtle Island features spacious lots shaded by live oaks, palmettos, and, of course, Southern wax myrtles, from which it likely draws its name. Streets are quiet, often ending in cul-de-sacs or dead-ends that enhance privacy. The overall ambiance is that of a nature-focused retreat where the sounds of birds and rustling trees dominate over traffic, appealing to those seeking a true escape.

Housing & Real Estate

The housing stock on Myrtle Island is predominantly composed of single-family homes, ranging from classic, elevated Tybee beach cottages to substantial modern coastal residences. Many homes are built on pilings, a practical design for the island's environment, and a significant number boast private docks on the tidal creeks or canals, offering direct access for kayaking, fishing, and boating. Lot sizes are generally generous, providing ample privacy and space for enjoying the natural surroundings.

Real estate prices on Myrtle Island are typically at a premium compared to other parts of Tybee, reflecting the desirable lot sizes, water access, and tranquil setting. The market includes both primary residences and vacation/second homes. While the area is primarily owner-occupied, a segment of the housing stock is available as seasonal or weekly rentals, though the community's vibe leans more toward long-term residency than the high-turnover vacation rental scene found elsewhere. Recent trends continue to show strong demand for properties with deep-water dock access and modern renovations.

Schools & Education

Myrtle Island is served by the Savannah-Chatham County Public School System. Students typically attend Tybee Island Maritime Academy (grades K-5) for elementary school, which is a unique Georgia charter school with a focus on marine science and coastal ecology—a perfect fit for island children. For middle and high school, students are zoned for schools on the mainland, such as Coastal Middle School and Islands High School, which involve a commute over the Lazaretto Creek bridge.

The draw of the Tybee Island Maritime Academy is significant for families living on Myrtle Island, as its specialized curriculum aligns seamlessly with the coastal lifestyle. For private education, families look to options in Savannah, including established institutions like Savannah Country Day School or Bible Baptist School. The educational environment here is closely tied to the community's deep connection with the coastal environment, with ample informal learning happening on the water and in the surrounding marshes.

Parks & Recreation

Recreation on Myrtle Island is intrinsically linked to its waterways and natural beauty. While the neighborhood itself is residential without formal public parks, it serves as a private gateway to unparalleled outdoor activities. Residents with docks have immediate access to kayaking, paddleboarding, and boating through the intricate network of creeks that feed into the Back River and Atlantic. Birdwatching and fishing from one's own property are daily pursuits for many.

Just minutes away, residents enjoy the vast, often less crowded stretch of North Beach at the tip of the island, adjacent to the Tybee Island Light Station and Museum. The nearby Fort Pulaski National Monument offers extensive historic grounds, walking trails, and picnic areas. For more active recreation, the Tybee Island Marine Science Center and the network of bike paths connecting the entire island are easily accessible, allowing Myrtle Island residents to engage with all of Tybee's amenities while returning to their quiet sanctuary.

Local Dining & Shopping

Myrtle Island's secluded nature means dining and shopping are found a short distance away in Tybee's main commercial districts. A quick trip to the island's center provides a variety of options, from the famous fresh seafood at The Crab Shack (located at the Lazaretto Creek entrance to the island) to casual bites at North Beach Bar and Grill. For groceries, the Tybee Island Market IGA is the primary full-service store, supplemented by smaller specialty shops and farmers' markets.

The vibe for Myrtle Island residents is often one of "stocking up" for a relaxed time at home, perhaps cooking a catch from their own dock. For a night out, the restaurants and shops along Tybrisa Street near the pier are a 10-minute drive, offering everything from ice cream and souvenirs to fine dining. The lack of immediate commercial development within Myrtle Island itself is precisely what residents cherish, valuing tranquility over convenience.

Who Lives Here

Myrtle Island attracts a demographic that values privacy, nature, and a deep connection to the coastal environment. The community is a mix of year-round Tybee locals, Savannah professionals seeking a peaceful retreat, and families who prioritize an active, outdoor lifestyle. Many residents are avid boaters, anglers, kayakers, and nature enthusiasts who directly utilize the water access their properties provide. There is a strong sense of being "in the know"—a part of Tybee that feels removed from the tourist hustle.

The community vibe is friendly and low-key, with neighbors bonded by a

Myrtle Island Market Data

Top Real Estate Agents in Myrtle Island, Tybee Island

Nearby Neighborhoods in Tybee Island, GA

← Back to all Tybee Island, GA real estate agents

← Back to all Georgia real estate agents