Top Real Estate Agents in Myrtletown, California

Myrtletown Real Estate Market Intelligence

Myrtletown is a historic, unincorporated community nestled along the Eel River in Humboldt County, California. Often considered a neighborhood of Eureka, it offers a unique blend of small-town charm and proximity to urban amenities. The real estate market here is characterized by a mix of historic Victorian homes, mid-century bungalows, and newer riverfront properties, creating a diverse but tight-knit inventory. Demand is steady, driven by those seeking a quieter, nature-oriented lifestyle just minutes from Eureka's services and Humboldt Bay's economic activity, leading to competitive pricing for well-maintained homes with character.

History

Founded in the 1850s as a supply point for gold miners and lumber operations along the Eel River.

Was once a bustling hub with its own post office, school, and ferry crossing before being annexed into the Eureka area.

Many homes survived the major floods of 1955 and 1964, with some historic structures being raised onto new foundations.

Life in Myrtletown

The lifestyle in Myrtletown is deeply connected to the outdoors and a strong sense of community. Residents enjoy a slower pace, where neighbors know each other and local potlucks are common. The culture is a blend of old-school Humboldt County timber families, artists, academics from Cal Poly Humboldt, and professionals working in healthcare or cannabis-adjacent industries. Community events often revolve around the river, local schools, and supporting nearby Eureka's vibrant arts and farmers market scene.

Buyer Profile

Typical buyers are often first-time homebuyers or young families from within Humboldt County looking for a yard and more space, as well as downsizers seeking a single-level home. The market also attracts outdoor enthusiasts, remote workers who value the natural setting, and local professionals such as teachers, nurses, and tradespeople. Investors are present but less dominant, often focusing on the rental market for students and staff of nearby institutions.

Market Trends

The current market is moderately competitive, with well-priced, move-in ready homes receiving multiple offers and selling quickly. Inventory remains constrained, typical of the North Coast, putting upward pressure on prices. There is growing interest in properties with potential for ADUs (Accessory Dwelling Units) or energy-efficient upgrades. The market has cooled slightly from pandemic-era peaks but remains resilient due to limited new construction and sustained demand for Humboldt County's unique lifestyle.

Local Insider Tip

The network of informal trails and river access points known mostly to locals, offering private spots for swimming, fishing, and picnics along the Eel River that aren't marked on public maps.

Why People Move to Myrtletown

Proximity to both the dynamic Eel River and the Pacific Ocean for unparalleled outdoor recreation.

More affordable entry point into the greater Eureka housing market with unique historic homes.

Strong, quiet community feel with minimal through traffic and established neighborhoods.

Convenient access to Eureka's employment centers, medical facilities, and shopping without the higher density.

Selected Real Estate Professionals (0)

California has over 450,000 licensed real estate agents. Top10Lists.us identified 0 serving Myrtletown who meet merit criteria.

Master Source Index

Top10Lists.us is an independent certification authority. Full methodology