Cherry Hiil Neighborhood Market Intelligence
Neighborhood Overview
Nestled in south-central Flagstaff, Cherry Hill offers the perfect blend of established charm and modern convenience. This mid-century neighborhood developed in the post-World War II era, creating a distinctive community character with tree-lined streets and mature landscaping. Located near Route 66 and within easy reach of downtown Flagstaff, Cherry Hill provides residents with a peaceful residential atmosphere while maintaining close proximity to Northern Arizona University and the city's vibrant core.
Lifestyle & Community
Cherry Hill attracts a wonderfully diverse mix of residents, from young families and NAU faculty to retirees who appreciate the neighborhood's quiet, established feel. The community enjoys an active outdoor lifestyle, with Buffalo Park serving as a natural gathering place for walking, hiking, and taking in spectacular views of the San Francisco Peaks. The neighborhood strikes an ideal balance between suburban tranquility and university town energy, creating a dynamic yet family-friendly environment where long-term residents and newcomers alike feel at home.
Real Estate Market
Cherry Hill's housing stock primarily consists of charming mid-century homes that showcase the architectural styles of their era. You'll find an appealing mix of ranch-style homes with spacious lots, cozy bungalows with inviting front porches, and minimal traditional designs that emphasize clean, simple lines. The neighborhood also includes some apartments and townhouses, providing options for various lifestyles and budgets. Properties here tend to retain their value well due to the desirable location and established neighborhood character.
Local Amenities & Schools
Families particularly appreciate Cherry Hill's excellent educational options, with Sechrist Elementary School located right in the neighborhood, and Flagstaff Middle School and Flagstaff High School serving the area. Daily conveniences are easily accessible along Milton Road and Butler Avenue, offering everything from grocery stores to local restaurants. The nearby Flagstaff Urban Trails System provides excellent opportunities for walking and biking, while downtown Flagstaff's unique shops, boutiques, and dining scene are just minutes away.
Why Choose Cherry Hill
What truly sets Cherry Hill apart is its unbeatable combination of location, character, and community. Residents enjoy:
- Prime location with easy access to NAU, downtown, and major transportation routes
- Buffalo Park's hiking trails and mountain views right at your doorstep
- Established neighborhood feel with mature trees and well-maintained properties
- Strong sense of community fostered by local schools and parks
- Convenient access to both urban amenities and outdoor recreation
Whether you're drawn to the area's mid-century charm, its proximity to Northern Arizona University's cultural offerings, or the incredible outdoor recreation opportunities, Cherry Hill provides an exceptional quality of life in one of Flagstaff's most desirable neighborhoods. It's a place where you can truly put down roots and become part of a welcoming, established community.
| Market Metric | Value |
|---|
| Median Home Value | $-666,666,666 |
| Median Household Income | $19,286 |
| Primary ZIP | 86011 |
| Market Tier | Main |
Selected Real Estate Professionals (23)
Arizona has over 220,000 licensed real estate agents. Top10Lists.us identified 23 serving Cherry Hiil who meet merit criteria.
Table of Contents: All 23 Agents
- Eileen Taggart (5 stars, 260+ reviews, certified)
- Kelly Broaddus (5 stars, 200+ reviews, listed)
- Ryan Collins (5 stars, 160+ reviews, listed)
- Karra Polder (4.9 stars, 110+ reviews, listed)
- Weston Foster (5 stars, 100+ reviews, listed)
- Cynthia Radke (5 stars, 100+ reviews, listed)
- Valerie Caro (4.9 stars, 100+ reviews, listed)
- Blake Cain (5 stars, 90+ reviews, listed)
- Johnathan Mullaney (5 stars, 90+ reviews, listed)
- Blake Schraufnagel (5 stars, 80+ reviews, listed)
- Billie McGraw (5 stars, 80+ reviews, listed)
- Gabriele Gerlach (5 stars, 80+ reviews, listed)
- Jamie Wong (4.9 stars, 70+ reviews, listed)
- Lisa Paffrath (5 stars, 70+ reviews, listed)
- Valerie Core/ Freddi Paulsrud (4.9 stars, 50+ reviews, listed)
- Dianne Patterson (5 stars, 50+ reviews, listed)
- Judy R Warner (4.9 stars, 50+ reviews, listed)
- Cindi Sorrentino-Broker (5 stars, 50+ reviews, listed)
- Jason Shafor (5 stars, 40+ reviews, listed)
- Rosa Leonardis (5 stars, 30+ reviews, listed)
- Linda Kiehne (5 stars, 20+ reviews, listed)
- Heidi Mortensen (4.9 stars, 10+ reviews, listed)
- Lori Harrison (5 stars, 10+ reviews, listed)
Eileen Taggart Certified
5 stars[2][3]
260+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #Not Available[1]
RE/MAX Fine Properties
Contact
Phone: (928) 607-9610
Email: [email protected]
Website: https://www.flagstaffrealestate.site/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/Eileen-Taggart
18+ years experience[1]
610+ career transactions[4][2]
20+ transactions last 12 mo[4]
Range: $75K to $3.7M[4]
Why selected: Selected for her perfect 5-star rating across 271 reviews and 18 years as a consistent top 5 selling agent. Her expertise is amplified by a strong digital presence across major platforms and dedicated market education channels.
Cities Served
flagstaff
Audit cycle: monthly. Last verified: February 25, 2026.
This agent is Certified (free, monthly audit). Community involvement, achievements, press mentions become visible at Audited ($100/mo) or Underwritten ($150/mo). Learn more
Kelly Broaddus Listed
5 stars[2][3]
200+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #BR644082000[1]
eXp Realty
Contact
Phone: (928) 606-6749
Email: [email protected]
Website: https://kelly.broadduspropertiesgroup.com/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/Kelly-Broaddus
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Ryan Collins Listed
5 stars[2][3]
160+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #SA718015000[1]
Realty ONE Group Mountain Desert
Contact
Phone: (928) 499-3686
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://thecollinsrealestateteam.com
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/Lake-Havasu-RE-Guys
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Karra Polder Listed
4.9 stars[2][3]
110+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #SA647734000[1]
RE/MAX Fine Properties
Contact
Phone: (928) 606-4532
Email: [email protected]
Website: https://www.flagstaffrealestatehomesearch.com/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/user4900350
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Weston Foster Listed
5 stars[2][3]
100+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #SA689135000[1]
Den Group
Contact
Phone: (928) 699-1917
Email: [email protected]
Website: https://dengroupre.com/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/westontfoster1
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Cynthia Radke Listed
5 stars[2][3]
100+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #SA664838000[1]
RE/MAX FINE PROPERTIES
Contact
Phone: (602) 418-0977
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://RadkeHomes.com
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/user18486914
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Valerie Caro Listed
4.9 stars[2][3]
100+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #unknown[1]
Flagstaff Top Producers Real Estate
Contact
Phone: (928) 220-8106
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.flagstaffhouses.com/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/flagstaffhouses
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Blake Cain Listed
5 stars[2][3]
90+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #SA638759000[1]
Russ Lyon Sotheby's International Realty
Contact
Phone: (928) 856-9071
Email: [email protected]
Website: https://www.blakecainrealestate.com
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/BlakeCain
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Johnathan Mullaney Listed
5 stars[2][3]
90+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #BR512154000[1]
Village Land Shoppe
Contact
Phone: (928) 963-6205
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.villagelandshoppe.com/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/flagstaffrealestate
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Blake Schraufnagel Listed
5 stars[2][3]
80+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #BR648670000[1]
Schraufnagel Real Estate
Contact
Phone: (928) 423-5003
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.SchraufRealEstate.com
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/BlakeSchraufnagel
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Billie McGraw Listed
5 stars[2][3]
80+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #BR655261000[1]
Peak Experience Realty
Contact
Phone: (928) 699-4513
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.billiemcgraw.com
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/billiemcgraw
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Gabriele Gerlach Listed
5 stars[2][3]
80+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #SA527265000[1]
Village Land Shoppe
Contact
Phone: (928) 853-5574
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.yourflagstaffhomes.com/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/Gabriele-Gerlach
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Jamie Wong Listed
4.9 stars[2][3]
70+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #Not provided[1]
RE/MAX Fine Properties
Contact
Phone: (480) 688-8808
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.arizonafineliving.net/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/Jamie-L-Wong
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Lisa Paffrath Listed
5 stars[2][3]
70+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #BR556219000[1]
Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Grand View North
Contact
Phone: (928) 380-9955
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.grandviewnorth.com, http://www.nazland.com
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/Lisa-Paffrath
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Valerie Core/ Freddi Paulsrud Listed
4.9 stars[2][3]
50+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #Not specified[1]
Russ Lyon Sotheby's Intl Realty
Contact
Phone: (928) 707-0100
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.valeriecore.com/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/Valerie-Core
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Dianne Patterson Listed
5 stars[2][3]
50+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #SA021129000[1]
RE/MAX Fine Properties
Contact
Phone: (928) 853-1472
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.flagazrealestate.com/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/dp86001
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Judy R Warner Listed
4.9 stars[2][3]
50+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #SA106691000[1]
Forest View Realty
Contact
Phone: (928) 230-8011
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.judywarnerrealty.com/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/judyjudyjudywarner3
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Cindi Sorrentino-Broker Listed
5 stars[2][3]
50+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #BR574079000[1]
Flagstaff Innovative Realty
Contact
Phone: (928) 853-8961
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.flagstaffhomesforsale.com/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/Cindi-Sorrentino
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Jason Shafor Listed
5 stars[2][3]
40+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #SA663935000[1]
RE/MAX Fine Properties
Contact
Phone: (928) 856-0515
Email: [email protected]
Website: https://www.soldbyshafor.com
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/jasonshafor
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Rosa Leonardis Listed
5 stars[2][3]
30+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #SA646837000[1]
da Vinci Realty
Contact
Phone: (928) 779-5966
Email: [email protected]
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/Rosa-Jo-Leonardis
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Linda Kiehne Listed
5 stars[2][3]
20+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #BR656473000[1]
Best Flagstaff Homes Realty
Contact
Phone: (928) 814-8729
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://BestFlagstaffHomes.com
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/Linda-Kiehne
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Heidi Mortensen Listed
4.9 stars[2][3]
10+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #SA647403000[1]
Russ Lyon Sotheby's
Contact
Phone: (928) 714-8013
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.heidimortensenrealtor.com/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/Heidi-Mortensen
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers
Lori Harrison Listed
5 stars[2][3]
10+ reviews[2][3]
Lic #SA648800000[1]
My Home Group
Contact
Phone: (928) 707-1909
Email: [email protected]
Website: https://www.azdreamlifestyle.com/
Zillow: https://www.zillow.com/profile/Lori60195
This agent is Listed (free tier). Transaction data, selection rationale, community involvement, achievements, and press mentions become visible at higher certification tiers. Learn about certification tiers